How to choose between the metal spring type and the hot-pressed protrusion type of membrane switches?
The metal spring type and the hot-pressed dome type are the two most common methods for achieving tactile sensations in membrane switches. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, and when choosing, it is necessary to consider multiple aspects comprehensively.
Comparison of Structure and Principle
Metal Spring Type (Pot Lid Spring): A stainless steel metal spring is placed under the key. When pressed, the spring collapses instantaneously to conduct the circuit, emitting a clear "click" sound. Once released, it automatically returns to its original state and disconnects. The spring not only provides tactile feedback but also serves as an electrical contact point for the circuit.
Hot Pressed Dome Type (Poly Dome): A dome-shaped structure with a raised top is formed by hot pressing a film material (usually PET) through a mold. When pressed, the dome deforms to conduct the circuit, relying on the material's own elasticity to return to its original state. The surface of the dome is printed with conductive silver paste as the contact points.
Core Parameter Comparison
| Comparison Dimensions | Metal Clip Type | Hot Pressed Bulb Type |
| Feel | Sharp, crisp, with strong paragraph sensation | Gentle, soft, with relatively weak paragraph sensation |
| Operating Force | 150~400 grams, uniform force | 50~200 grams, customizable force |
| Key Press Sound | Clear "click" sound | Slight dull sound, relatively quiet |
| Service Life | More than 500,000 to 1,000,000 times | More than 500,000 times |
| Working Temperature | -20℃ to 80℃ | Key pressing force may weaken under high temperature |
| Insert Plate Requirements | Must be flat and have good rigidity | Relatively loose requirements |
| Mold Cost | No mold opening required (standard clip specification) | Requires hot press mold opening, higher cost |
| Single-piece Cost | Higher (clip + assembly) | Moderate (lower after mold amortization) |
| Thickness | Relatively thick (clip height 0.1~0.3mm) | Relatively thin (bulb height 0.3~0.7mm) |
Advantageous scenarios for metal spring-type components
High operation confirmation requirements: In scenarios such as industrial control panels, medical equipment, and financial terminals, operators need a clear "click" feedback to confirm that each operation has taken effect, to avoid repeated pressing or missed presses.
Wearing gloves for operation: In scenarios where gloves need to be worn, such as in factory workshops and outdoor equipment, the sharp segments of the metal spring can effectively compensate for the loss of tactile sensation.
High reliability requirements: In scenarios such as military and aerospace, where life and stability are extremely critical, stainless steel spring components have excellent corrosion resistance and fatigue resistance.
Flexible spring specifications: Common specifications include circular, cross-shaped, triangular, and waist-shaped, with diameters ranging from 3 to 20mm, and force ranging from 100 to 5000 grams, suitable for different operation needs.
Advantageous scenarios for hot-pressed convex type:
Ultra-thin design: Products with strict thickness requirements (such as portable devices, ultra-thin panels) do not require additional spring-clip layers for the convex type, making the overall design thinner.
Curved installation: Metal spring-plates require the backing plate to be absolutely flat, while the convex type has lower requirements for the flatness of the substrate, making it more suitable for installation surfaces with certain curvature.
Medium budget, medium hand feel requirements: Consumer-grade products such as home appliance panels (microwave ovens, washing machines), office equipment, etc., the convex type provides a compromise solution of "having a feel but not noisy".
Mass production with standardization: Although it requires mold production, once the mold is completed, the single-piece cost of mass production is lower than that of the metal spring-plate type, making it suitable for large-scale orders.
Selection Considerations
Metal spring-type
The backing plate must be flat: If the backing plate is not flat or is adhered to a surface with excessive curvature, the spring may cause short circuits, malfunctions or fail to spring back.
It is recommended to use a thicker PCB: If it is used as the circuit layer, it is recommended to directly use a thickened PCB board as the backing plate to ensure uniform force distribution on the spring.
Spring plate specification recommendation: Generally, 10-12mm diameter springs are recommended, which are more suitable for the area of finger pressing.
Hot-pressed convex type
Mold quality determines consistency: Convex mold is recommended to be made with a metal die to ensure consistency in key pressing force and stroke. Ordinary molds are prone to causing significant differences in the feel of each key.
Pay attention to heat attenuation: When used in a high-temperature environment for a long time, the elasticity of the convex material may weaken, resulting in a decrease in key pressing force. If the working temperature of the product exceeds 70℃, it is recommended to prefer the metal spring type first.
Recommendation for convex size: The diameter of the silver paste raised part is recommended to be 8-10mm. If it is too small, it will affect the pressing experience.
Quick selection decision
Do you need an extremely crisp "click" feel?
├─ Yes → Select the metal spring type
└─ No → Is the installation surface flat?
├─ No (has curvature / is uneven) → Select the hot-pressed protrusion type
└─ Yes → Is the working temperature above 70℃?
├─ Yes → Select the metal spring type
└─ No → Is the budget sensitive?
├─ Yes (large batch) → Select the hot-pressed protrusion type
└─ No → Both are fine, prefer the metal spring type (better feel)
💡 Summary: The metal shrapnel type has a sharp feel, high reliability, and a wide applicable temperature range. However, it requires high flatness of the liner plate and has a relatively high cost. The hot-pressed bulge type is thinner, has lower requirements for the installation surface, and offers better cost-effectiveness for large-scale production. However, its strength may weaken at high temperatures and the mold cost is higher. For critical industrial control and medical applications, the metal shrapnel type should be preferred; for consumer-grade applications such as household appliances and office equipment, the hot-pressed bulge type can be chosen.
